The verdict came on a Tuesday, three days after the trial concluded, which was faster than Ji Heng had expected and slower than he had feared. He received the call from the court clerk at ten-fifteen in the morning while he was in his office, staring at the forensic diagram of the upward-angle wound and trying to compose an appeal brief that he hoped he would never need to file. The clerk's voice was neutral, giving nothing away. "The court will convene at two o'clock this afternoon to deliver the judgment in case number NC-2002-047. Please inform your client."
Ji Heng hung up and sat very still. The afternoon judgment meant the judges had deliberated through the weekend, which could be a good sign or a bad sign. Quick verdicts usually meant guilty; very long deliberations sometimes meant a holdout. Three days was the ambiguous middle, the zone where anything was possible. He called the detention center and arranged to meet Shen Mo before the transport. Then he called Xiao Zhang and told her to bring the mitigation files to the courthouse by one-thirty.
The detention center visiting room was colder than usual, or perhaps Ji Heng was simply noticing the cold more. Shen Mo was brought in without shackles—a small courtesy for the pre-verdict conference—and he sat down across from Ji Heng with the rigid posture of a man who had already begun to brace himself against an impact he could not see.
"They will deliver the verdict this afternoon," Ji Heng said.
Shen Mo nodded. His face had thinned further during the trial, the cheekbones sharp enough to cast shadows. "What do you think it will be?"
"I think the judges listened carefully. I think they recognized the weaknesses in the witness testimony. I think the procedural issues gave them pause." Ji Heng paused. He was constitutionally incapable of lying to his clients, but he was also constitutionally incapable of crushing them. "The death penalty is possible. I want you to be prepared for that. But it is not certain. There are grounds for appeal either way."
"What about life imprisonment?"
"That is also possible. If the court accepts the excessive self-defense argument, even partially, they may impose a fixed term or life. It depends on how they weigh the mitigating factors."
Shen Mo was silent for a moment. Then, in a voice so quiet Ji Heng had to lean forward to hear it, he said, "I keep thinking about the phone call. The stranger who asked for Lao Zhao. If I had just hung up. If I had walked a different street. If I had left the phone at home. None of this would have happened."
"Probably not," Ji Heng said. "But the law does not judge hypotheticals. It judges what happened."
"They should. Hypotheticals are the only thing that matter. Everything else is already done."
Ji Heng had no answer to that. He had been a lawyer for twenty-two years, and he had never found a satisfactory response to the problem of contingency—the way lives pivoted on moments so small they were invisible until they were catastrophic. The law pretended that actions had clear meanings, that intentions could be inferred from outcomes, that the chain of causation was a straight line rather than a tangle of accidents and near-misses. But Ji Heng knew better. He had seen too many cases in which the difference between a life sentence and a death sentence was a matter of centimeters, of seconds, of a stranger's misdialed phone call.
"I will be with you at the verdict," Ji Heng said. "Whatever happens, we will respond. There are always next steps."
Shen Mo looked at him, and for the first time since they had met, his eyes held something that was not quite despair. It was not hope, either. It was something smaller and more stubborn—a refusal to be erased. "Thank you," he said. "For everything. Even if it does not work."
Ji Heng nodded and stood, and the guards came to take Shen Mo back to his cell.
The courtroom at two o'clock was even more crowded than it had been during the trial. Word had spread through the courthouse that a capital verdict was coming, and the benches were filled with clerks and bailiffs and off-duty officers, along with the journalists who had been covering the case for the Nancheng Evening News. Lin Wan was in her usual seat in the front row, wearing the same black jacket, her mother-in-law beside her. Song Ming's mother had aged visibly in the weeks since the funeral; her face had collapsed into itself, the skin loose and gray, her eyes fixed on the empty judge's chair with the intensity of prayer.
Ji Heng sat at the defense table with Xiao Zhang, who was shuffling papers with nervous hands. The prosecution table was occupied by Gao Zhenming and two junior procurators, their faces composed into expressions of calm professionalism. The courtroom hummed with the low frequency of collective anticipation.
At precisely two-fifteen, Judge Wei entered through the side door, flanked by the two associate judges. The courtroom rose, sat, and fell into absolute silence. Judge Wei adjusted her glasses and unfolded a sheaf of papers. Her expression was unreadable, the expression of a woman who had delivered many verdicts and had learned to keep her own feelings out of sight.
"This court has heard the evidence in the case of the People versus Shen Mo, charged with intentional homicide in violation of Article 232 of the Criminal Code," she began. Her voice was dry and precise, the voice of someone reading a train schedule. "The court has reviewed the testimony, the physical evidence, the forensic analysis, and the arguments of counsel. The court has deliberated and reached a verdict."
She paused. The silence in the room was so complete that Ji Heng could hear the fluorescent lights buzzing overhead.
"On the charge of intentional homicide, the court finds the defendant guilty."
A sound moved through the gallery—not quite a gasp, not quite a murmur, something between the two. Ji Heng closed his eyes briefly. He had expected this. The confession, the flight, the knife, the dead man—these were not things that could be argued away. Guilt had never been the question. The question was the sentence.
"The defendant's claim of excessive self-defense is not supported by the evidence," Judge Wei continued. "Eyewitness testimony established that the victim raised his hands in a gesture of surrender and stepped backward before the fatal blow. The defendant produced a concealed weapon during a verbal dispute and employed it with lethal force. The victim was unarmed. The defendant fled the scene and evaded arrest for two days. These facts are inconsistent with a claim of self-defense, excessive or otherwise."
Ji Heng felt Xiao Zhang stiffen beside him. He put a hand on her arm, a small, steadying pressure.
"In determining the sentence, the court has considered the following aggravating factors: the use of a concealed weapon in a public place, the flight from justice, and the severity of the harm caused. The court has also considered the following mitigating factors: the defendant's lack of prior criminal record, his expression of remorse, and the chaotic and rapidly unfolding nature of the confrontation, which the court acknowledges was not premeditated."
Ji Heng leaned forward. The acknowledgment of chaos and the absence of premeditation was a small victory—too small to change the verdict, but possibly enough to influence the sentence.
"Having weighed these factors, the court sentences the defendant, Shen Mo, to death, with a two-year reprieve."
The words landed in the room like stones dropped into still water. Ji Heng exhaled slowly. A death sentence with a two-year reprieve was not the worst possible outcome. Under Chinese law, a two-year reprieve meant the sentence would be suspended for two years; if the defendant showed good behavior during that time, the death sentence would be automatically commuted to life imprisonment. It was, in practice, a life sentence, though the condemned man would spend two years waiting to learn which version of his future would arrive.
But before Ji Heng could process the sentence fully, Gao Zhenming rose from his seat. His face was composed, but his voice carried an edge that Ji Heng had not heard during the trial.
"Your Honor, the prosecution respectfully objects to the sentence. The People have sought the death penalty with immediate execution. The defendant's crime—a public stabbing of an innocent citizen, followed by flight—meets the statutory threshold for the most severe punishment. The mitigating factors cited by the court are insufficient to justify a reprieve. The prosecution requests that the court reconsider the sentence and impose death with immediate execution."
Judge Wei looked at Gao over the rim of her glasses. "The court has considered the prosecution's recommendation and has determined that a two-year reprieve is appropriate given the specific circumstances of the case. However, in light of the prosecution's objection, the court will refer the sentence to the Provincial Higher Court for automatic review, as required by law."
Ji Heng felt the floor shift beneath him. The automatic review was standard procedure for all death sentences, but Gao's objection had turned it into something more adversarial. The Higher Court would now review the case with the prosecution's objection on the record, and the pressure to impose immediate execution—especially in a case that had attracted public attention—would be significant.
He rose to his feet. "Your Honor, the defense requests leave to submit additional mitigation evidence to the Higher Court during the review process."
"Granted," Judge Wei said. "The court will forward the complete case file, including all defense submissions, to the Provincial Higher Court within thirty days. This court is adjourned."
The gavel fell, and the courtroom erupted into motion. Guards moved to take Shen Mo away; journalists rushed for the doors; spectators stood and began to talk in low, urgent voices. Lin Wan remained seated, her face white, her hands clenched in her lap. Ji Heng could not tell whether she was relieved or devastated. A death sentence with a reprieve was still a death sentence in name, and for a woman who had wanted the ultimate punishment, the qualifier might feel like a betrayal. But it was also, in practical terms, a life sentence, and that might feel like a different kind of betrayal—the system acknowledging that her husband's life was worth less than the full weight of the law.
Ji Heng walked to the defense table and began gathering his papers. Shen Mo was being led toward the side door, and before he disappeared, he turned and met Ji Heng's eyes. His face was pale, but he was not crying. He raised his cuffed hands in a small, awkward gesture—half a wave, half a salute—and then he was gone.
"The Higher Court will uphold the sentence," Xiao Zhang said, her voice tense. "They rarely overturn a trial court's sentencing decision."
"They rarely do," Ji Heng agreed. "But the prosecution's objection changes things. Gao is not just asking the Higher Court to uphold the sentence. He is asking them to increase it. To immediate execution."
"Can they do that?"
"The law permits it. The Higher Court can affirm, reduce, or increase a sentence during the automatic review. If they find that the trial court was too lenient, they can impose immediate execution." Ji Heng closed his briefcase. "We need to prepare the mitigation submission. And we need to find something new—something the trial court did not fully consider."
He walked out of the courtroom and into the corridor, where the late-afternoon light was already beginning to fade. Lin Wan was standing by the window, alone. She did not turn when he approached.
"Mrs. Lin," Ji Heng said quietly. "I am sorry for your loss. I know this verdict does not bring you peace."
She turned then, and her eyes were dry but burning. "He is going to live," she said. "Your client is going to live, and my husband is dead. Where is the justice in that?"
"The reprieve means he will serve at least two years in prison, and likely the rest of his life if he behaves well. He will not walk free."
"But he will walk. He will breathe. He will eat meals and read books and write letters. My husband will do none of those things." Her voice cracked. "You stood there and argued that the knife was opened with two hands instead of one. You argued about seconds and angles and pauses. But the result is the same. My husband is dead. Your client killed him. And now your client gets to live."
Ji Heng had no answer that would satisfy her. He had learned, long ago, that victims' families did not want legal reasoning. They wanted acknowledgment of the irreparable, and the law was not designed to provide that. "The Higher Court will review the sentence," he said. "The prosecution has asked for immediate execution. If that happens, your husband's death will be answered with the full penalty of the law."
Lin Wan stared at him. "And if it does not?"
"Then the system will have determined that the circumstances warranted a lesser punishment. I cannot tell you what the Higher Court will do. I can only tell you that the law is not finished with this case yet."
She turned back to the window. The city outside was gray and indifferent, the streets filling with the usual evening traffic. "The law," she said quietly, "has never been finished with anything. It just keeps going, and the people who are hurt by it keep going too, and nothing ever really ends."
Ji Heng stood beside her for a moment, looking out at the same gray sky, and then he walked away, down the courthouse steps and into the street. He had a mitigation submission to write. He had a client to save from a worse fate than the one he had already received. And he had, somewhere in the back of his mind, the nagging sense that the case was not over—that the verdict was not an ending but a pivot, a turn toward something he could not yet see.
The first verdict had fallen. But the system was still in motion, and Ji Heng knew, from twenty-two years of practice, that a system in motion was a system that could be pushed.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!