The Mountain View Motel was a misnomer in every sense. It did not have a view of the mountains, unless one stood on a chair in the parking lot and craned one's neck at an uncomfortable angle. It was not, strictly speaking, in Wrenhaven proper, but on a stretch of highway two miles south of town that had been bypassed by the new road in 1986 and had been slowly returning to forest ever since. And it was not really a motel so much as a collection of twelve rooms arranged in an L-shape around a cracked concrete courtyard, their doors painted a shade of green that had been fashionable during the Eisenhower administration.
Cassia had checked into Room 7 the previous evening, after her conversation with Cora Hale. She had chosen the room because it was at the far end of the building, away from the highway, with a window that looked out onto the forest. She had spent the night sitting in the dark, watching the parking lot through the curtains, waiting for the dark car to appear. It never did. But she had not slept, and by morning her eyes were gritty and her nerves were stretched thin.
She was still certain she had been followed. The car in the turnout near Fire Road had been real, not a figment of her exhausted imagination. Someone had been watching Cora's cabin. Someone had seen Cassia arrive and leave. And that someone now knew that a stranger had come to Wrenhaven asking questions about a murder that was supposed to have been buried by a hurricane sixteen years ago.
She spent the morning at the Copper Kettle, nursing coffee and trying to decide what to do next. Cora had given her the testimony she needed—a description of the man with the limp, walking into Windfall House during the eye of the storm, holding a letter opener. It was circumstantial, but combined with Finnick Hale's meteorological data and the child's drawing and Elara's diary entries, it painted a picture that was close to definitive. Gideon Ashford had killed his mother. The senator's family had set the stage. And the storm had provided the cover.
But Cora refused to testify. Without her testimony, the case was still just a collection of fragments, suggestive but not conclusive. Cassia needed something more. Something that would force the authorities to reopen the investigation.
She was on her third cup of coffee when the door of the Copper Kettle opened and a man walked in who made her heart stop.
He was tall and weathered, with dark hair going gray at the temples and a face that had spent decades exposed to sun and wind. He wore a canvas coat and carried a battered notebook. And when he saw Cassia in the booth by the window, he walked directly toward her and sat down across from her without waiting for an invitation.
"Finnick Hale," Cassia said, her voice barely concealing her surprise. "What are you doing in Wrenhaven?"
"The same thing you are," Finnick said. "Looking for Cora Lindqvist." He gestured to the waitress for coffee, then turned his pale blue eyes back to Cassia. "I've been coming to this town every year for the past decade. I never found her. But you did."
"How do you know that?"
"Because I followed you. Not all the way from Danforth—I'm not that obsessive. But I've been monitoring the Historical Society's communications since the diary was found. When you requested a leave of absence and checked out a vehicle from the motor pool, I knew you were on to something. I drove up yesterday. I saw your car at the diner, and then I saw you drive up Fire Road." He paused, accepting the coffee from the waitress with a nod of thanks. "I also saw the other car. The dark sedan with the Kennebec plates. It was parked in the turnout near Cora's cabin."
Cassia felt the knot in her stomach tighten. "You saw it too."
"I saw it. And I saw the driver. A man, late fifties, gray suit, cold eyes. He was watching your car through binoculars. When you came down from the cabin, he followed you as far as the motel, then turned off toward the highway. I don't know where he is now."
"The man with the cold eyes," Cassia murmured. "Cora told me about him. He came to Havenmoor after the murder, asking questions. He's been looking for her for sixteen years."
"He works for the Whitmore family," Finnick said. "I've been investigating them for years. They're the ones who sent the letters. They're the ones who orchestrated the whole thing."
"Whitmore?" Cassia's mind raced. "Maeve's married name is Whitmore. Ashford-Whitmore."
"Yes. And the senator—the twins' father—was Theodore Whitmore. He was the patriarch of the Whitmore family, the most powerful political dynasty in Kennebec. He served in the state senate for thirty years. His brother was governor. His nephew is currently the Senate Majority Leader. If it came out that Theodore Whitmore had an affair with Elara Ashford and fathered twin boys out of wedlock, the scandal would destroy the family's reputation and quite possibly their political empire."
Cassia sat back in the booth, her coffee forgotten. Theodore Whitmore. The name was familiar, a figure from history books and newspaper archives, a man whose portrait hung in the Kennebec State Capitol with a plaque describing him as a "statesman of unimpeachable integrity." And all along, he had been hiding a secret that would have ended his career and tarnished his family's name for generations.
"How did you find all this out?" she asked.
"I told you. I've been investigating this case for sixteen years." Finnick opened his battered notebook, revealing pages dense with handwritten notes and newspaper clippings and meteorological charts. "The Whitmore family knew about the twins. Theodore Whitmore knew about the twins. He was there at St. Agatha's Hospital on the night they were born. He signed the adoption papers for Sebastian under a false name. He paid Vera Drummond to keep quiet. And he threatened Elara Ashford—told her that if she ever revealed the truth, he would destroy her and her family."
"But Elara kept a photograph of him. She kept it in the strongbox with the drawing."
"She kept it as insurance. She knew that as long as she had proof of the affair, the Whitmores couldn't touch her. But after Theodore died in the plane crash in 1991, the photograph became a liability. The new generation of Whitmores—Theodore's nephew, Harold Whitmore, and his cousin, Margaret Whitmore-Crane—were even more determined to protect the family's reputation. They found out about the twins. They found out about Elara's plan to change her will. And they decided to act."
"They sent the letters," Cassia said. "They sent them to Elara, to Gideon, to Sebastian. They brought them all together before the storm."
"Exactly. They knew about Gideon's temper. They knew he had been disinherited. They knew he would be enraged by the revelation about Sebastian and the change to the will. They gambled that he would confront Elara, that things would escalate, and that the storm would cover up whatever happened." Finnick's voice was bitter. "They didn't pull the trigger, but they loaded the gun and pointed it at Elara Ashford's heart."
Cassia thought about Maeve. Maeve Ashford-Whitmore. Maeve had married into the Whitmore family. She had taken their name, joined their social circles, accepted their patronage. Had she known? Had she been part of the conspiracy, or had she been used by them just like everyone else?
"Maeve," Cassia said slowly. "Maeve's married name is Whitmore. She's connected to the family."
"I know. I've been trying to determine her involvement for years. She may have been complicit, or she may have been a pawn. Either way, she's not the one we need to worry about right now." Finnick leaned forward, his pale eyes intense. "The man in the dark sedan is still out there. He knows you talked to Cora. He's going to try to stop you from leaving Wrenhaven with what you know."
"Stop me how?"
"I don't know. But I think we should find out before he makes his move." Finnick stood up, throwing a few bills on the table. "I'm staying at the same motel as you. Room 11. If you see anything suspicious, call me. And whatever you do, don't go anywhere alone."
He walked out of the diner, leaving Cassia alone with her cold coffee and her racing thoughts. The Whitmore family. The senator. The conspiracy. It all made a terrible kind of sense. The letters had been the catalyst, the spark that ignited a powder keg of secrets and resentments that had been building for decades. Gideon had been the weapon. The storm had been the cover. And the Whitmores had orchestrated it all from a safe distance, their hands technically clean, their motives buried under layers of proxies and intermediaries.
But there was still one piece missing. The man with the cold eyes. The enforcer who had been sent to Wrenhaven to make sure Cora Lindqvist never told anyone what she had seen.
Cassia spent the afternoon at the motel, trying to rest, trying to think. She called the Historical Society and asked for an extension of her leave. She called her neighbor and asked her to continue feeding the cats. And then she called a number she had not dialed in weeks, a number she had been carrying in her notebook since her first visit to Breakwater.
Gideon Ashford answered on the fifth ring. His voice was slurred, as if he had been drinking, but he was coherent enough to understand what she was telling him.
"I found the witness," Cassia said. "I found Cora Lindqvist. She saw someone walk into Windfall House during the eye of the storm. Someone with a limp. Someone carrying a letter opener."
There was a long silence on the other end of the line. Then Gideon spoke, and his voice was different than she had ever heard it—quieter, more defeated, stripped of its usual bravado.
"I've been waiting for this call for sixteen years," he said. "I knew someone would find her eventually."
"Then you admit it. You were there. You killed your mother."
Another silence. Then: "I didn't kill her. I was there. I walked to the house during the eye. But when I got to the library, she was already dead. The letter opener was already in her chest. Someone else got there first."
Cassia's blood ran cold. "That's not possible. The eye was only eleven minutes long. Cora saw a man with a limp enter the house."
"I had a limp. I'd injured my knee on the way there. But I wasn't the only one." Gideon's voice cracked. "There was another man. He was already in the house when I arrived. I saw him leaving through the conservatory as I was coming in. I didn't see his face, but I saw his eyes. Cold eyes. Eyes like a dead fish."
Cassia gripped the phone so hard her knuckles turned white. "The man from Kennebec. The Whitmore family's enforcer."
"He killed her," Gideon said. "He killed her, and he let me take the blame. I've been carrying this for sixteen years, and I've never told anyone because I knew no one would believe me. Why would they? I had the motive. I had the opportunity. I had the letter opener—it was from my mother's desk, something I'd seen a hundred times. My fingerprints would have been all over it anyway. The perfect setup."
"Then why are you telling me now?"
"Because you found Cora. Because the truth is coming out whether I want it to or not. And because—" Gideon's voice broke. "Because I'm tired. I'm tired of the whiskey and the lies and the dreams about that night. I didn't kill my mother, Miss Vance. I hated her, but I didn't kill her. And if there's any justice left in the world, the man with the cold eyes will finally pay for what he did."
The line went dead. Cassia stared at the phone, her mind reeling. Gideon's confession—and it was a confession, even if it wasn't to murder—changed everything. If he was telling the truth, then the real killer was still out there. The Whitmore family's enforcer. The man with the cold eyes. The man who had been following her in Wrenhaven.
She looked out the window of her motel room. The sun was setting, and the shadows were lengthening across the parking lot. And there, parked at the edge of the lot, half-hidden by a stand of pines, was a dark sedan with Kennebec plates that had not been there an hour ago.
Cassia reached for her phone and dialed Finnick's room. No answer. She tried his cell. No answer. She looked out the window again, and her heart nearly stopped.
The door of the dark sedan was opening. And the man who stepped out—tall, gray-suited, his eyes cold even at a distance—was walking toward the motel.
Toward her room.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!